The Emotional Logic of Great Talks: Why some speakers connect and others collapse

Interested in learning more about speechwriting and public speaking courses? Find my courses here.  

Since the COVID lockdown, I’ve helped hundreds of speakers. From TEDx hopefuls to global keynote veterans, I’ve helped them rediscover their voice because they’ve become completely disconnected from how they sound when they speak.

They’re not alone. Most people don’t lose their voice all at once. They bury it, under expertise, perfectionism, and a pile of expectations about how they’re “supposed” to sound.

And when they finally stand up to give a talk, they wonder:Why didn’t it land? Why didn’t my talk connect?

Sometimes it’s the structure.Often, it’s the delivery. But more than anything else? It’s a misunderstanding of emotional logic.

Emotional Logic ≠ Emotional Manipulation

Let me tell you a story that still makes me mad.

A few years ago, one of my clients had been assigned a “TEDx speaker coach.” This coach told them with a straight face, “The goal of your talk is to make the audience cry.”WHAT?! That’s not just bad advice. It’s a total misunderstanding of what makes a talk work.

Your job as a speaker isn’t to trigger tears. It’s to guide emotion.

Yes, tears might happen. Laughter might happen. A pause-filled, breathless silence might happen. But those things are byproducts of well-structured emotional movement. Not the goal.

I also have people tell me all the time, “Can you write me a talk that keeps the audience on their feet the entire time?”

That sounds like a good idea ... in theory. But in reality? That request tells me they don’t understand the role of emotion in speaking.

Because emotion isn’t about hype. It’s about motion.

Emotion Is How You Move the Audience—Literally

Here’s what I mean:

Emotion guides the audience from where they are to where you want them to go. 

If you try to start with inspiration but haven’t earned their trust or curiosity, it won’t land. If you push too hard too early, they shut down.

That’s why the best speeches don’t just “add heart.” They follow an emotional arc that makes sense.

From TEDx to Keynotes: What I’ve Seen

I once worked with a TEDx speaker who had a story that should’ve cracked the room wide open. Growing up in violence, finding freedom through education, and eventually becoming a professional who helps others process their trauma.

But when she initially shared her story with me? It fell flat. Not because the story wasn’t powerful. But because it lacked emotional progression.

She had stacked trauma on trauma. It was overwhelming. So we rebuilt it. We shaped the story. We gave it a clear emotional arc:

• From shame to self-trust

• From powerlessness to purpose

• From isolation to impact

• 
  

We didn’t strip out emotion. We gave it structure. We created emotional logic so the audience could follow, feel, and move with her.

The Emotional Arc of Resonance

Here’s the structure I use when coaching speakers through emotional logic. It’s not a formula, but it’s a helpful map:

1. Frustration

Start with the itch the audience already feels. The unspoken tension. The friction they can’t name.

That’s where empathy is born.

2. Search

Now show the struggle. The real, messy process of trying to find clarity, or answers, or relief. This is where you earn credibility: not by knowing but by wrestling.

3. Shift

Then comes the breakthrough. Not the polished solution, but the moment something clicked. A change in perspective. A turn in the road. A crack in the old frame.

4. Lift

End with expansion. Help the audience see themselves in a new way. Show them what’s possible. Not with hype but with clarity and resonance.

Why This Matters

Great talks don’t succeed because the speaker is “dynamic.” They succeed because the speaker guides emotion with intention.

If you want your talk to connect, ask yourself:

• Where am I starting them emotionally?

• What tension do they already feel?

• Where do I want to take them?

• And am I moving them step-by-step—or leaping over the part where they need to be seen first?

  
  

Emotion isn’t the goal. It’s the vehicle. It’s how you journey with your audience. Not just at them, but with them.

That’s the difference between a speaker who connects… and one who collapses.